Domain Name News: “ICANN tells US Court that ccTLDs are not property and thus cannot be seized”

---

ICANN tells US Court that ccTLDs are not property and thus cannot be seized Posted: 30 Jul 2014 07:07 AM PDT Files Motion to Quash in U.S. legal action aimed at Seizing Top-Level Domains The Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) has told a U.S. federal court in the District of Columbia, that a country code Top-Level Domain (ccTLD) cannot be considered "property," and thus cannot be attached by plaintiffs in a lawsuit, who are trying to obtain the assets of countries that they argued have supported terrorism. "We filed a Motion to Quash in the US federal court today, to ensure that the court has the essential information about how the Internet's domain name system (DNS) works. While we sympathize with what plaintiffs may have endured, ICANN's role in the domain name system has nothing to do with any property of the countries involved", said John Jeffrey, ICANN's General Counsel and Secretary. "We explained in our Motion to Quash, that country code Top-Level Domains (ccTLD) are part of a single, global interoperable Internet which ICANN serves to help maintain." Jeffrey further explained that "ccTLD's are not property, and are not 'owned' or 'possessed' by anyone including ICANN, and therefore cannot be seized in a lawsuit." ICANN's arguments were put forth when the victims of terrorism who had successfully won lawsuits against Iran, Syria and North Korea, sought to collect on those civil judgments.  In their attempt to recover assets from these countries, the plaintiffs served ICANN with "writs of attachment" and subpoenas seeking information to help them seize the ccTLDs of those nations. The ccTLDs (and related IP addresses) targeted by the plaintiffs include; .IR (Iran), .SY (Syria) and .KP (North Korea), as well as internationalized top-level domains in non-ASCII characters for Iran and Syria. ICANN explains the motion as follows: First, a ccTLD simply is not "property" subject to attachment. Second, although operating for the benefit of the people of Iran, Syria and North Korea, respectively, the relevant ccTLDs are not "owned" by the defendants or anyone else, for that matter. Third, the .IR, .SY and .KP ccTLDs are not "located" in the District of Columbia or even the United States, and therefore are beyond the reach of Plaintiffs' Writs of Attachment. Fourth, even if these ccTLDs could be characterized as "property in the United States of the defendants," this Court would lack jurisdiction over these proceedings, according to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. Fifth, ICANN does not unilaterally have the capability or authority to transfer the .IR, .SY or .KP ccTLDs to Plaintiffs. Finally, a forced transfer of the .IR, .SY and .KP ccTLDs would destroy whatever value may exist in these ccTLDs, would wipe out the hundreds of thousands of second-level domain names registered therein by various individuals, businesses and charitable organizations, and could jeopardize the single, global, interoperable structure the Internet. [via Press Release] Related posts: Court dismisses IOD’s .WEB lawsuit against ICANN 4 IDN ccTLDs pass String Validation Phase Are Domain Names Considered Property or Not? German Court: It’s not OK to register country names ICANN to Delay Release of New gTLDs, Speeds up Release of IDN ccTLDs

You are subscribed to email updates from Domain Name News (DNN) To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now.	Email delivery powered by Google
Google Inc., 20 West Kinzie, Chicago IL USA 60610

Read more

Domain, top 5 stories on Domain Name Wire last month

***********************************
Domain Name Wire for Domain
July 2, 2014
Top Domain Name Stories from June
***********************************


Run Your TLD with KSregistry!

The KSregistry GmbH as a technical backend provider
offers features and functions to successfully
operate your registry. The customer-specific
KSregistry solution can be expanded and modified
according to changing needs at all times.
For more information, please visit:

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZvWj&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=p&


(sponsor)


**********************************


Welcome to the DomainNameWire.com newsletter.

Moniker takes three spots on June's top 5 stories
at Domain Name Wire. Here are the top 5:

1. The new Moniker: Love it or Hate it?

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZvXV&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=W&


2. Moniker CEO Bonnie Wittenburg discusses botched transition

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZvvN&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=A&


3. ICM interview: Lessons on premium domains, marketing and more

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZv22&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=8&


4. Why Google is becoming a domain name registrar & what it means for the business

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZveh&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=I&


5. Sorry, Moniker. It's Over.

http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZvoY&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=3&


***************************

Stop by DNW.com to read these other
domain industry headlines


* Over 800,000 domain names suspended due to 2013 RAA

* .London ads spotted in London last week

* Impressive results from .Global domain name auction

* Uniregistry inks distribution deal with GoDaddy




These stories are just a sample of what you can read at DomainNameWire.com.
Domain Name Wire is read by domainers, domain registrars, attorneys,
public officials, and Fortune 500 company brand managers.



**************************************
You are subscribed to the Domain Name Wire newsletter.

Visit Domain Name Wire at http://domainnamewire.net/click.html?x=a62b&lc=wZvHR&mc=BK&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=K&

Powered by: http://domainnamewire.net/referral.html?x=a62b&u=MT&y=T&


Brainstorm Labs, LLC, PO Box 163411, Austin, TX 78733, United States


To unsubscribe visit:
http://domainnamewire.net/me.html?x=a62b&m=hszMx&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=K&
To change your contact details visit:
http://domainnamewire.net/me.html?x=a62b&m=hszMx&s=V0alB&u=MT&y=K&

Read more